
Sephora kicked off the holiday season with a new campaign starring Seth Rogen. The “Sethphora” takeover has sparked many valid critiques around marketing, retail and beauty. However, there’s much more to consider about comedy, celebrity partnerships and representation.
If you want to make Sephora a fun place to shop and you’ve hired one of the best comedians, then where are all the good jokes? I’m curious how much Seth Rogen was involved in the planning stage. Was he even consulted on the script or did he just memorize it? I feel like if you gave him an hour, he could’ve made this so much stronger and funnier.
“My brow gets cold in Canadian winters,” he says in an ad. Seriously? AI could write better jokes without making Canada sound ridiculous.
If you hire A-list comics, then you should lean on their expertise to make it really funny. Otherwise, you just created a lot of expensive and embarrassing content. The Jeopardy clip about being in “Sephora without my glasses” was way more shareable than this campaign.
Sephora pairs Seth with a lovely beauty advisor to help him navigate the store for holiday shopping. She’s a solid casting choice, but again, their interactions suffer from a weak script.
No matter how charming the sales team is in-store, they don’t know your friends and family or their wish lists. If you have no idea what skincare or scents someone likes, then why are you shopping for a gift at Sephora in the first place? A gift card might sound like a last resort, but at least it could help specific needs rather than a random product a sales associate recommended.
That said, there are some decent jokes about what’s popular today like pimple patches. I like how Seth introduces his mom to LED face masks – the latest craze if you can afford it. There’s a clear effort to include timely examples, but not enough to justify hiring a legendary comedian like Seth Rogen.
Seth Rogen is also Jewish, so there’s a missed opportunity to include that and mention Hannukah, especially when Sephora made so many short videos to support the campaign.
Unfortunately, the size of Sephora’s budget doesn’t match the quality of their script. There’s still that temptation to pick up last minute Christmas gifts at the drugstore.
Follow me on Instagram & LinkedIn for interviews with industry leaders. Let’s chat about the hottest brands, latest trends and the business of Hollywood!
